Pennsylvania Background Check: State Requirements

Introduction

Pennsylvania stands as one of the most industrious states in the nation, home to over 12.8 million residents and a diverse economy spanning manufacturing, healthcare, education, and energy sectors. From the bustling streets of Philadelphia to the steel heritage of Pittsburgh, employers across the Keystone State rely on thorough background screening to make informed hiring decisions while navigating complex state and federal compliance requirements.

Pennsylvania’s approach to background check regulations creates a unique landscape that differs significantly from federal law in several key areas. The state has implemented specific protections for job applicants with criminal records, established strict consent requirements for employers, and created industry-specific screening mandates that go beyond what federal regulations require. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for employers operating in Pennsylvania.

State laws matter because they often provide greater protection for job seekers than federal minimums while imposing additional obligations on employers. Pennsylvania’s regulations can override federal standards when they’re more restrictive, creating a compliance framework that requires careful attention to both state-specific requirements and federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) guidelines. Failure to comply with Pennsylvania’s background check laws can result in significant penalties, lawsuits, and regulatory action.

State Background Check Laws

Pennsylvania’s background check framework is primarily governed by the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act (PHRA), which works in conjunction with various industry-specific statutes and administrative regulations. The PHRA prohibits employment discrimination and establishes specific requirements for how criminal history information can be used in hiring decisions.

The Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission (PHRC) serves as the primary regulatory agency responsible for enforcing fair employment practices, including background check compliance. The PHRC has authority to investigate complaints, issue guidance, and impose penalties for violations of state employment law. Additionally, the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services oversees background check requirements for childcare and healthcare workers, while the Department of Education manages screening requirements for school employees.

Enforcement of Pennsylvania’s background check laws occurs through multiple channels. The PHRC can initiate investigations based on employee complaints or compliance audits, leading to cease and desist orders, monetary penalties, and requirements for policy changes. Private individuals can also file lawsuits under state law for violations of background check procedures, potentially resulting in damages, attorney fees, and injunctive relief.

Pennsylvania courts have consistently held that employers must demonstrate a direct relationship between criminal convictions and job responsibilities when making adverse employment decisions. This standard goes beyond federal requirements and creates additional compliance obligations for Pennsylvania employers.

Ban the Box / Fair Chance

Pennsylvania does not have a comprehensive statewide “Ban the Box” law that applies to all private employers. However, the state has implemented fair chance hiring requirements for state government positions, removing criminal history questions from initial job applications and delaying background checks until later in the hiring process.

Several major Pennsylvania municipalities have enacted their own Ban the Box ordinances that significantly impact hiring practices. Philadelphia’s Fair Criminal Record Screening Ordinance prohibits employers with five or more employees from inquiring about criminal history on job applications and requires individualized assessments before making adverse decisions based on criminal records. Pittsburgh has implemented similar restrictions, and other municipalities continue to consider comparable legislation.

These local ordinances typically establish timing restrictions that prevent employers from conducting criminal background checks until after extending a conditional job offer or completing an initial interview. The specific timing varies by jurisdiction, making it essential for multi-location employers to understand the requirements in each area where they operate.

Even without a comprehensive statewide ban, Pennsylvania employers must be cautious about blanket exclusions based on criminal history. The Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission has issued guidance indicating that automatic disqualification policies may violate state anti-discrimination laws unless there’s a clear business justification and direct relationship to job duties.

Criminal Record Rules

Pennsylvania maintains specific rules governing how long criminal records can be considered in employment decisions, though these lookback periods vary by industry and offense type. For most private employers, Pennsylvania law doesn’t establish universal lookback limits, but the PHRC recommends considering the nature of the offense, time elapsed since conviction, and relevance to job responsibilities.

Certain industries have specific lookback requirements. Healthcare positions subject to state licensing may require disclosure of all criminal convictions regardless of age, while some positions have seven-year or ten-year lookback periods for specific offense categories. Financial services employers must comply with federal regulations that may impose different timeframes than state requirements.

Pennsylvania law distinguishes between different types of reportable offenses. Felony convictions are generally reportable without time limitations unless expunged, while misdemeanor offenses may have different reporting requirements. Summary offenses, Pennsylvania’s lowest level of criminal offense, typically have limited impact on employment eligibility except in specific industries like childcare or elder care.

The state has established comprehensive expungement and record sealing procedures that directly impact background check results. Pennsylvania’s Clean Slate Act provides automatic sealing of certain criminal records after specified waiting periods, while traditional expungement procedures allow individuals to petition courts for record removal. Once a record is expunged or sealed under Pennsylvania law, it should not appear in employment background checks, and applicants can legally deny the existence of expunged offenses.

Employers must understand that expunged records are legally considered never to have occurred under Pennsylvania law. Using expunged information in hiring decisions or requiring disclosure of expunged offenses can result in legal liability and discrimination claims.

Employer Obligations

Pennsylvania employers must obtain clear, written consent before conducting background checks, meeting both state and federal requirements. The consent must be provided on a standalone document separate from job applications, clearly explain the scope of the background check, and inform applicants of their rights under state and federal law. Pennsylvania law requires specific disclosures about how criminal history information will be used in hiring decisions.

The adverse action process in Pennsylvania involves multiple steps that go beyond federal FCRA requirements. Before making a final decision based on background check results, employers must provide applicants with a copy of the background report and allow a reasonable opportunity to respond. Pennsylvania’s individualized assessment requirement means employers must consider factors like the nature of the offense, time elapsed, evidence of rehabilitation, and job relevance before making final decisions.

Pennsylvania employers must also provide specific notices when taking adverse action based on criminal history. These notices must explain the basis for the decision, identify the specific conviction(s) that led to the adverse action, and provide information about the applicant’s right to challenge the accuracy of the information or provide additional context about the conviction.

Record keeping requirements in Pennsylvania mandate that employers maintain documentation of their background check procedures, consent forms, and adverse action decisions. These records must be preserved for specific periods and made available for regulatory review. Employers must also document their individualized assessment process to demonstrate compliance with state anti-discrimination requirements.

Industry-Specific Rules

Pennsylvania’s healthcare sector faces comprehensive background check requirements that vary based on specific roles and licensing requirements. Healthcare workers with direct patient access must undergo state and federal criminal background checks, including FBI fingerprint checks. The Pennsylvania Department of Health maintains specific disqualifying offense lists for different healthcare positions, with some convictions creating permanent bars to employment while others allow for individualized review processes.

Long-term care facilities must conduct particularly thorough screenings, including checks of state abuse registries and ongoing monitoring of employee criminal records. Pennsylvania law requires healthcare employers to conduct periodic re-screening of employees in certain positions, creating ongoing compliance obligations beyond initial hiring.

Educational institutions in Pennsylvania operate under strict background check requirements established by the Pennsylvania Department of Education. All school employees, contractors, and volunteers with direct student contact must undergo comprehensive background screening, including Pennsylvania State Police criminal history checks, FBI fingerprint checks, and child abuse clearances from the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services.

Pennsylvania’s educational background check requirements include specific disqualifying offenses that create automatic bars to school employment. However, the state also provides waiver processes for certain convictions, allowing individuals to petition for employment eligibility based on rehabilitation evidence and other mitigating factors.

Financial services employers in Pennsylvania must comply with both state requirements and federal regulations like the FDIC’s Section 19 requirements. These rules often create more restrictive screening requirements than general Pennsylvania employment law, including broader disqualifying offense categories and longer lookback periods.

Other regulated industries, including childcare, elder care, and transportation, have specific screening requirements that may include specialized background check components, ongoing monitoring requirements, and industry-specific disqualifying criteria.

Best Practices for Compliance

Pennsylvania employers should develop comprehensive background check policies that address state-specific requirements while maintaining consistency with federal law. These policies should clearly define the scope of background checks for different positions, establish individualized assessment procedures, and provide specific guidance for handling criminal history information.

Implementing individualized assessment procedures is crucial for Pennsylvania compliance. Employers should train hiring managers to consider multiple factors when evaluating criminal history, document their decision-making process, and maintain consistent application of their policies across all applicants. This includes establishing clear criteria for job-relatedness and developing standardized forms for documenting assessment decisions.

Common pitfalls in Pennsylvania include applying blanket disqualification policies, failing to conduct individualized assessments, inadequate consent procedures, and insufficient adverse action notifications. Employers frequently struggle with understanding local Ban the Box requirements and applying different standards across multiple jurisdictions within the state.

Staying updated on Pennsylvania background check requirements requires monitoring multiple sources of information. The Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission regularly issues guidance and policy updates, while local jurisdictions may modify their ordinances. Staffing Agency Background can change through regulatory updates or legislative action, making ongoing compliance monitoring essential.

Employers should establish relationships with qualified background check providers who understand Pennsylvania’s specific requirements and can ensure ongoing compliance with changing regulations. Regular policy reviews and staff training help maintain compliance as laws evolve.

FAQ

Q: How long do employers in Pennsylvania have to wait before conducting background checks?

A: This depends on location and local ordinances. While Pennsylvania doesn’t have a statewide Ban the Box law for private employers, cities like Philadelphia and Pittsburgh require employers to wait until after conditional job offers or initial interviews before conducting criminal background checks. State government positions follow fair chance hiring practices that delay background checks until later in the process.

Q: Can Pennsylvania employers automatically reject applicants with criminal records?

A: No, Pennsylvania law requires individualized assessments for applicants with criminal records. Employers must consider factors like the nature of the offense, time elapsed since conviction, evidence of rehabilitation, and job relevance before making hiring decisions. Blanket disqualification policies may violate state anti-discrimination laws unless clearly job-related and justified by business necessity.

Q: What types of criminal records are automatically sealed in Pennsylvania?

A: Pennsylvania’s Clean Slate Act automatically seals certain criminal records, including summary convictions after five years, misdemeanor convictions with sentences of two years or less after ten years (if no subsequent convictions), and charges that resulted in non-conviction dispositions after 60 days. Once sealed, these records should not appear in employment background checks.

Q: Do Pennsylvania background check requirements apply to contractors and volunteers?

A: Yes, certain industries require background checks for contractors and volunteers. Educational institutions must screen contractors and volunteers with direct student contact, while healthcare facilities may need to screen contractors with patient access. The specific requirements depend on the industry, role responsibilities, and level of access to vulnerable populations.

Q: How often must Pennsylvania employers re-screen employees?

A: Re-screening requirements vary by industry. Most private employers have no ongoing re-screening obligations, but healthcare facilities, especially long-term care providers, may need to conduct periodic re-screening of employees in sensitive positions. Educational institutions typically don’t require ongoing re-screening unless there are specific concerns or policy changes.

Conclusion

Navigating Pennsylvania’s background check requirements demands careful attention to state-specific laws, local ordinances, and industry regulations that often exceed federal minimums. From Philadelphia’s Ban the Box ordinance to comprehensive healthcare screening requirements, Pennsylvania employers must balance thorough due diligence with fair chance hiring practices and individualized assessment obligations.

Success in Pennsylvania’s complex compliance environment requires understanding the interplay between state anti-discrimination laws, local fair chance hiring ordinances, and industry-specific screening mandates. Employers who develop comprehensive policies, implement individualized assessment procedures, and maintain ongoing compliance monitoring will be best positioned to make informed hiring decisions while avoiding legal pitfalls.

Ready to ensure your Pennsylvania background checks are compliant and comprehensive? BackgroundChecker.com provides fast, affordable, and FCRA-compliant background screening solutions designed for individuals, landlords, small businesses, and enterprise HR teams. Our easy online process delivers clear, accurate reports while our dedicated support team helps you navigate Pennsylvania’s complex compliance requirements. With transparent pricing and quick turnaround times, BackgroundChecker.com makes professional background screening accessible and reliable. Start your compliant Pennsylvania background check today and experience the confidence that comes from working with a trusted screening partner.